Joe Carter Price List
Last publish date: Oct 25, 2023
Note: even though this may be a recent publish, I sell through different avenues. My apologies if I end up being sold out of something I have listed.
An order form is at the bottom of the page, but other options are available at the Ordering Process page.
Last publish date: Oct 25, 2023
Note: even though this may be a recent publish, I sell through different avenues. My apologies if I end up being sold out of something I have listed.
An order form is at the bottom of the page, but other options are available at the Ordering Process page.
| YEAR | DESCRIPTION | PRICE | IMAGE | Link to Set | Team |
| 1984 | Replay Games Card (no pic) | $2.00 | INDIANS | ||
| 1984 | Statis Pro - Avalon Hill Game Card (no pic) | $2.00 | INDIANS | ||
| 1985 | Replay Games Card (no pic) | $2.00 | INDIANS | ||
| 1985 | Statis Pro - Avalon Hill Game Card (no pic) | $2.00 | INDIANS | ||
| 1986 | Donruss Highlights #42 | $0.50 | INDIANS | ||
| 1986 | MLB Its Okay to Say No to Drugs 8x10 Coloring Book Page (on cardstock) | $3.00 |  | INDIANS | |
| 1986 | OPC #377 | $1.00 | INDIANS | ||
| 1986 | OPC Sticker #213 | $2.00 | INDIANS | ||
| 1986 | OPC Tattoo Strip #15 of 24 (Tito Landrum/Hal McRae/Joe Carter/ Jeff Leonard/Tony Fernandez/Juan Samuel/Buddy Bell /Willie Randolph) | $3.00 | INDIANS | ||
| 1986 | Statis Pro - Avalon Hill Game Card (no pic) | $2.00 | INDIANS | ||
| 1986 | Topps Sticker #213 | $0.75 | INDIANS | ||
| 1986 | Topps Tattoo | $0.75 | INDIANS | ||
| 1987 | Classic Yellow #127 | $0.75 | INDIANS | ||
| 1987 | Donruss Opening Day #109 | $0.75 | INDIANS | ||
| 1987 | Fleer Award Winners #08 | $0.50 | INDIANS | ||
| 1987 | Fleer Baseball All-Stars #08 | $0.50 | INDIANS | ||
| 1987 | Fleer Glossy #249 | $3.00 | INDIANS | ||
| 1987 | Fleer League Leaders #09 | $0.50 | INDIANS | ||
| 1987 | Fleer Limited Edition #07 | $0.50 | INDIANS | ||
| 1987 | Fleer Mini #19 | $0.75 | INDIANS | ||
| 1987 | Fleer Star Sticker #21 | $0.50 | INDIANS | ||
| 1987 | Kaybee #09 | $0.50 | INDIANS | ||
| 1987 | Kraft #15 | $1.00 |  | http://www.supercollectorcatalog.com/1987-kraft-variations.html | INDIANS |
| 1987 | Kraft Panel Variation (Joe Carter/Ozzie Smith) | $4.00 |  | http://www.supercollectorcatalog.com/1987-kraft-variations.html | INDIANS |
| 1987 | Kraft Panel Variation (Joe Carter/Pete Rose) | $4.00 |  | http://www.supercollectorcatalog.com/1987-kraft-variations.html | INDIANS |
| 1987 | Kraft Panel Variation (Joe Carter/Steve Sax) | $2.00 | http://www.supercollectorcatalog.com/1987-kraft-variations.html | INDIANS | |
| 1987 | Kraft Panel Variation (Joe Carter/Vince Coleman) | $2.00 | http://www.supercollectorcatalog.com/1987-kraft-variations.html | INDIANS | |
| 1987 | Kraft Sample #15 (White Stock Variation) | $30.00 |  | http://www.supercollectorcatalog.com/1987-kraft-samples.html | INDIANS |
| 1987 | M&M's #16 | $0.50 | INDIANS | ||
| 1987 | M&M's Panel of 2 (Kirby Puckett/Joe Carter) | $2.00 | INDIANS | ||
| 1987 | OPC #220 | $1.00 | INDIANS | ||
| 1987 | OPC Sticker #208 | $1.50 | INDIANS | ||
| 1987 | Red Foley Cover Mini (blue) | $1.00 |  | http://www.supercollectorcatalog.com/1987-red-foley-stickers.html | INDIANS |
| 1987 | Red Foley Sticker #027 | $1.00 |  | http://www.supercollectorcatalog.com/1987-red-foley-stickers.html | INDIANS |
| 1987 | Replay Games Card (no pic) | $2.00 | INDIANS | ||
| 1987 | Smokey the Bear A.L. Postcard #05 | $2.00 | INDIANS | ||
| 1987 | Sportflics #176 | $1.00 | INDIANS | ||
| 1987 | Sportflics Team Preview #03 (Joe Carter/Mel Hall/ Cory Snyder/Brook Jacoby/Greg Swindell/Tom Candiotti /Pat Tabler/Julio Franco/Phil Niekro/Ken Schrom/Brett Butler/Tony Bernazard) | $1.50 | INDIANS | ||
| 1987 | Statis Pro - Avalon Hill Game Card (no pic) | $2.00 | INDIANS | ||
| 1987 | Stuart Cakes #18 | $3.00 | INDIANS | ||
| 1987 | Stuart Cakes Panel of 3 (Joe Carter/Pat Tabler/Julio Franco) | $4.00 | INDIANS | ||
| 1987 | Topps Coin #07 | $0.75 | INDIANS | ||
| 1987 | Topps Gallery of Champions Aluminum | $4.00 | INDIANS | ||
| 1987 | Topps Glossy Send In Set of 60 #16 | $0.75 | INDIANS | ||
| 1987 | Topps Mini League Leader #51 | $0.50 | INDIANS | ||
| 1987 | Topps Sticker #208 (blue print on back/Made in Italy) | $0.75 | INDIANS | ||
| 1987 | Topps Sticker #208 Hard Back/Test Issue (blue print on back/ No "Made in Italy") | $1.50 | INDIANS | ||
| 1987 | Topps Tiffany #220 | $1.50 | INDIANS | ||
| 1988 | APBA Game Card (no pic) | $1.50 | INDIANS | ||
| 1988 | Donruss Opening Day #56 | $0.75 | INDIANS | ||
| 1988 | Fleer Baseballs Best #07 | $0.50 | INDIANS | ||
| 1988 | Fleer Glossy #605 | $2.50 | INDIANS | ||
| 1988 | Fleer Mini #18 | $1.00 | INDIANS | ||
| 1988 | Fleer Star Sticker #18 | $0.75 | INDIANS | ||
| 1988 | Fleer Superstars #06 | $0.50 | INDIANS | ||
| 1988 | Grenada Stamp #NNO | $3.00 | http://www.supercollectorcatalog.com/1988-grenada-stamp-sheets.html | INDIANS | |
| 1988 | Grenada Stamp Sheet of 9 (George Brett, Joe Carter, Frank Robinson, Mel Ott, Benito Santiago, Ted Higuera, Llody Moseby, Bobby Bonilla, Warren Spahn) | $8.00 |  | http://www.supercollectorcatalog.com/1988-grenada-stamp-sheets.html | INDIANS |
| 1988 | Leaf #184 | $0.50 | INDIANS | ||
| 1988 | Nestle #36 | $1.00 | INDIANS | ||
| 1988 | Nestle Panel (Bill Doran/Jose Uribe/Joe Carter) | $3.00 | INDIANS | ||
| 1988 | OPC #75 | $1.00 | INDIANS | ||
| 1988 | OPC Blank Back Error | $3.00 | INDIANS | ||
| 1988 | OPC Sticker Variations (Dave Parker #19/Joe Carter #213) | $0.50 | INDIANS | ||
| 1988 | OPC Sticker Variations (Eric Davis #14/Joe Carter #213) | $0.50 | INDIANS | ||
| 1988 | OPC Sticker Variations (Joe Carter #49/Albert Hall #39 - Ken Williams #287) | $0.50 | INDIANS | ||
| 1988 | OPC Sticker Variations (Joe Carter #49/Bob Brenly #92 - Sam Horn #246) | $0.50 | INDIANS | ||
| 1988 | OPC Sticker Variations (Joe Carter #49/Dave Magadan #104 - Scott Fletcher #241) | $0.50 | INDIANS | ||
| 1988 | OPC Sticker Variations (Joe Carter #49/Dennis Martinez #84 - Mike Dunne #307) | $0.50 | INDIANS | ||
| 1988 | OPC Sticker Variations (Joe Carter #49/Franklin Stubbs #66 - Danny Tartabull #257) | $0.50 | INDIANS | ||
| 1988 | OPC Sticker Variations (Joe Carter #49/Kevin Gross #118 - Gene Larkin #279) | $0.50 | INDIANS | ||
| 1988 | OPC Sticker Variations (Joe Carter #49/Leon Durham #63 - Luis Polonia #172) | $0.50 | INDIANS | ||
| 1988 | OPC Wax Box Card #I | $2.00 | INDIANS | ||
| 1988 | Panini Sticker #72 | $0.75 | INDIANS | ||
| 1988 | Panini Sticker #74 | $0.75 | INDIANS | ||
| 1988 | Panini Sticker #75 | $0.75 | INDIANS | ||
| 1988 | Replay Games Card (no pic) | $2.00 | INDIANS | ||
| 1988 | Score Glossy #80 | $3.00 | INDIANS | ||
| 1988 | Sportflics #5 | $1.00 | INDIANS | ||
| 1988 | Starting Lineup Card (red) | $2.00 | INDIANS | ||
| 1988 | Statis Pro - Avalon Hill Game Card (no pic) | $2.00 | INDIANS | ||
| 1988 | Topps Coin | $1.00 | INDIANS | ||
| 1988 | Topps Rite Aid #17 | $0.75 | INDIANS | ||
| 1988 | Topps Sticker Variations (Jack Morris #59/Joe Carter #213) | $0.50 | INDIANS | ||
| 1988 | Topps Sticker Variations (Joe Carter #49/Bob Welch #73 - Charlie Hough #236) | $0.50 | INDIANS | ||
| 1988 | Topps Sticker Variations (Joe Carter #49/Casey Candaele #77 - Rich Gedman #252) | $0.50 | INDIANS | ||
| 1988 | Topps Sticker Variations (Joe Carter #49/Chris Brown #111 - Dave Stewart #168) | $0.50 | INDIANS | ||
| 1988 | Topps Sticker Variations (Joe Carter #49/Eddie Murray #233) | $0.50 | INDIANS | ||
| 1988 | Topps Sticker Variations (Joe Carter #49/Frankin Stubbs #66 - Danny Tartabull #257) | $0.50 | INDIANS | ||
| 1988 | Topps Sticker Variations (Joe Carter #49/Jose Canseco #173) | $0.50 | INDIANS | ||
| 1988 | Topps Sticker Variations (Joe Carter #49/Kevin Gross #118 - Gene Larkin #279) | $0.50 | INDIANS | ||
| 1988 | Topps Sticker Variations (Joe Carter #49/Mark Langston #214) | $0.50 | INDIANS | ||
| 1988 | Topps Sticker Variations (Joe Carter #49/Mike Schmidt #149) | $0.50 | INDIANS | ||
| 1988 | Topps Sticker Variations (Joe Carter #49/Mike Sciosica #67 - Steve Buechele #235) | $0.50 | INDIANS | ||
| 1988 | Topps Sticker Variations (Joe Carter #49/Willie Randolph #294) | $0.50 | INDIANS | ||
| 1988 | Topps Sticker Variations (Jose Canseco #48/Joe Carter #213) | $0.50 | INDIANS | ||
| 1988 | Topps Sticker Variations (Mike Schmidt #8/Joe Carter #213) | $0.50 | INDIANS | ||
| 1988 | Topps Sticker Variations (Roger Clemens #58/Joe Carter #213) | $0.50 | INDIANS | ||
| 1988 | Topps Tiffany #75 | $3.00 | INDIANS | ||
| 1988 | Topps Tiffany #789 | $2.00 | INDIANS | ||
| 1988 | Topps Tiffany U.K. Mini #12 | $2.00 | INDIANS | ||
| 1988 | Topps U.K. Mini #12 | $0.75 | INDIANS | ||
| 1988 | Topps Wax Box Card #I (dark stock variation) | $1.50 |  | INDIANS | |
| 1988 | Topps Wax Box Card #I (light back variation) | $1.50 |  | INDIANS | |
| 1988 | Topps Wax Box Panel of 4 Light Stock Variation (Joe Carter/Eric Davis/ Howard Johnson/ Darryl Strawberry) | $3.00 |  | INDIANS | |
| 1989 | Baseball Card Magazine Insert #36('59 Topps Replica) | $1.50 | http://www.supercollectorcatalog.com/1989-baseball-card-magazine-inserts-59-topps.html | INDIANS | |
| 1989 | Bowman Tiffany #091 | $1.00 | INDIANS | ||
| 1989 | Cadaco Disc #NNO (No Team/League Variation) | $1.50 |  | http://www.supercollectorcatalog.com/1989-cadaco-disc-variations.html | INDIANS |
| 1989 | Cadaco Disc #NNO (Team/League Variation) | $3.00 |  | http://www.supercollectorcatalog.com/1989-cadaco-disc-variations.html | INDIANS |
| 1989 | Classic Light Blue #11 | $0.75 | INDIANS | ||
| 1989 | Donruss Baseball's Best #056 | $0.50 | INDIANS | ||
| 1989 | Fleer Exciting Stars #04 | $0.75 | INDIANS | ||
| 1989 | Fleer Glossy #400 | $1.00 | INDIANS | ||
| 1989 | Fleer Heroes of Baseball #06 | $0.75 | INDIANS | ||
| 1989 | OPC Sticker Variations (Gary Carter #55/Joe Carter #216) | $0.50 | INDIANS | ||
| 1989 | OPC Sticker Variations (Joe Carter #14/Andy McGaffigan #75 - Bert Blyleven #285) | $0.50 | INDIANS | ||
| 1989 | OPC Sticker Variations (Joe Carter #14/Dave Smith #13 - Mickey Tettleton #231) | $0.50 | INDIANS | ||
| 1989 | OPC Sticker Variations (Joe Carter #14/Jeff Robinson #129 - Scott Bradley #225) | $0.50 | INDIANS | ||
| 1989 | OPC Sticker Variations (Joe Carter #14/Kelly Downs #81 - Mitch Williams #247) | $0.50 | INDIANS | ||
| 1989 | OPC Sticker Variations (Kirk Gibson #49/Joe Carter #216) | $0.75 | INDIANS | ||
| 1989 | Panini Sticker #327 | $0.75 | INDIANS | ||
| 1989 | Red Foley Cover Mini (green) | $0.50 |  | http://www.supercollectorcatalog.com/1989-red-foley-stickers.html | INDIANS |
| 1989 | Red Foley Sticker #020 | $1.00 | http://www.supercollectorcatalog.com/1989-red-foley-stickers.html | INDIANS | |
| 1989 | Replay Games Card (no pic) | $2.00 | INDIANS | ||
| 1989 | Score Superstar #55 | $1.00 | INDIANS | ||
| 1989 | Scoremasters #34 | $0.50 | INDIANS | ||
| 1989 | Sportflics #104 | $1.00 | INDIANS | ||
| 1989 | Statis Pro - Avalon Hill Game Card (no pic) | $2.00 | INDIANS | ||
| 1989 | Topps Ames 20/20 Club #09 | $0.75 | INDIANS | ||
| 1989 | Topps Baseball Talk/ LJN #104 | $2.00 | INDIANS | ||
| 1989 | Topps Big #155 | $0.50 | INDIANS | ||
| 1989 | Topps Hills Team MVPs #06 | $0.75 | INDIANS | ||
| 1989 | Topps Sticker Variations (Andres Galaragga #36/Joe Carter #216) | $0.50 | INDIANS | ||
| 1989 | Topps Sticker Variations (Gary Carter #55/Joe Carter #216) | $0.50 | INDIANS | ||
| 1989 | Topps Sticker Variations (Joe Carter #14/Andy Van Slyke #132) | $0.50 | INDIANS | ||
| 1989 | Topps Sticker Variations (Joe Carter #14/Chris Sabo #142) | $0.50 | INDIANS | ||
| 1989 | Topps Sticker Variations (Joe Carter #14/Don Carman #121) | $0.50 | INDIANS | ||
| 1989 | Topps Sticker Variations (Joe Carter #14/Jeff Treadway #139 - Carlton Fisk #299) | $0.50 | INDIANS | ||
| 1989 | Topps Sticker Variations (Joe Carter #14/Lance McCullers #108 - Mike Witt #176) | $0.50 | INDIANS | ||
| 1989 | Topps Sticker Variations (Joe Carter #14/Lou Whitaker #282) | $0.50 | INDIANS | ||
| 1989 | Topps Sticker Variations (Joe Carter #14/Mark Grace #50 - Cory Snyder #210) | $0.50 | INDIANS | ||
| 1989 | Topps Sticker Variations (Joe Carter #14/Mike Marshall #67 - Jim Presley #223) | $0.50 | INDIANS | ||
| 1989 | Topps Sticker Variations (Joe Carter #14/Paul Molitor #146) | $0.50 | INDIANS | ||
| 1989 | Topps Sticker Variations (Joe Carter #14/Randy Myers #97 - Bob Boone #175) | $0.50 | INDIANS | ||
| 1989 | Topps Sticker Variations (Joe Carter #14/Robin Yount #205) | $0.50 | INDIANS | ||
| 1989 | Topps Sticker Variations (Joe Carter #14/Roger Clemens #259) | $0.50 | INDIANS | ||
| 1989 | Topps Sticker Variations (Mike Greenwell #16/Joe Carter #216) | $0.50 | INDIANS | ||
| 1989 | Topps Sticker Variations (Steve Sax #39/Joe Carter #216) | $0.50 | INDIANS | ||
| 1989 | Topps Tiffany #420 | $1.50 | INDIANS | ||
| 1989 | Topps U.K. Mini #13 | $1.00 | INDIANS | ||
| 1989 | TV Sports Mailbag Inc #085 (8x10) | $4.00 |  | INDIANS | |
| 1990 | Bandai Collectors Coin | $3.00 | PADRES | ||
| 1990 | Bowman Tiffany #220 | $2.00 | PADRES | ||
| 1990 | Classic Blue #138 | $0.50 | INDIANS | ||
| 1990 | Classic Pink #T9 | $0.50 | PADRES | ||
| 1990 | Donruss Best NL #72 | $0.75 | PADRES | ||
| 1990 | Leaf #379 | $1.00 | PADRES | ||
| 1990 | OPC #580 | $1.00 | PADRES | ||
| 1990 | Panini Sticker #065 | $0.75 | INDIANS | ||
| 1990 | Post #30 | $0.50 | INDIANS | ||
| 1990 | Post Panel of 2 (Dwight Gooden/Joe Carter) | $3.00 |  | INDIANS | |
| 1990 | Publication International Hottest 50 Player Stickers | $1.50 |  | http://www.supercollectorcatalog.com/1990-publication-international-hottest-50-players-stickers.html | INDIANS |
| 1990 | Publication International Trivia Sticker - 1 | $0.50 |  | http://www.supercollectorcatalog.com/1990-publication-international-trivia-stickers.html | INDIANS |
| 1990 | Publication International Trivia Sticker - 2 | $0.50 | http://www.supercollectorcatalog.com/1990-publication-international-trivia-stickers.html | INDIANS | |
| 1990 | Publication International Trivia Sticker Panel of 4 | $1.50 |  | INDIANS | |
| 1990 | Red Foley Sticker #15 | $1.00 | http://www.supercollectorcatalog.com/1990-red-foley-stickers.html | INDIANS | |
| 1990 | Replay Games Card (no pic) | $2.00 | PADRES | ||
| 1990 | SCD Price Guide Insert Panel of 5 - '57 Topps Replica (Michael Jordan/Glenn Davis/ Marquis Grissom/Joe Carter/Greg Jefferies) | $4.00 |  | PADRES | |
| 1990 | SCD Price Guide Magazine Insert #54 ('57 Topps Replica) | $1.50 | http://www.supercollectorcatalog.com/1990-scd-price-guide-magazine-inserts-57-topps.html | PADRES | |
| 1990 | Score Superstar #59 | $0.50 | INDIANS | ||
| 1990 | Sportflics #120 | $1.00 | INDIANS | ||
| 1990 | Statis Pro - Avalon Hill Game Card (no pic) | $2.00 | INDIANS | ||
| 1990 | Topps Ames All-Star #27 | $0.50 | PADRES | ||
| 1990 | Topps Big #071 (C*D* Copyright Variation) | $0.75 | INDIANS | ||
| 1990 | Topps Big #245 (F* Copyright Variation) | $0.75 | PADRES | ||
| 1990 | Topps Doubleheader | $3.00 | INDIANS | ||
| 1990 | Topps Doubleheader (no stand) | $3.00 | INDIANS | ||
| 1990 | Topps Hills Hit Men #28 | $0.50 | PADRES | ||
| 1990 | Topps Mini League Leader #13 | $0.50 | INDIANS | ||
| 1990 | Topps Sticker Variations (Bobby Bonilla #7/Joe Carter #209) | $0.50 | INDIANS | ||
| 1990 | Topps Sticker Variations (Joe Carter #48/Gary Redus #127 - Cecil Espy #249) | $0.50 | INDIANS | ||
| 1990 | Topps Sticker Variations (Joe Carter #48/Tom Browning #135 - Steve Farr #270) | $0.50 | INDIANS | ||
| 1990 | Topps Sticker Variations (Joe Carter #48/Tom Herr #122 - Rafael Palmeiro #250) | $0.50 | INDIANS | ||
| 1990 | Topps Sticker Variations (Ryne Sandberg #6/Joe Carter #209) | $0.50 | INDIANS | ||
| 1990 | Topps T.V. All-Star #43 | $3.00 | PADRES | ||
| 1990 | Topps Tiffany #580 | $1.00 | INDIANS | ||
| 1990 | Topps Tiffany Traded #20T | $2.00 | PADRES | ||
| 1991 | Baseball Card Magazine Insert #51('66 Topps Replica) | $1.50 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1991 | Baseball Card Magazine Strip of 3 - '66 Topps (Dave Winfield/ Twins Rookies/Joe Carter) | $3.00 |  | BLUE JAYS | |
| 1991 | Baseball Card Price Guide Magazine Insert #12('71 Topps ) | $1.50 | http://www.supercollectorcatalog.com/1991-baseball-card-price-guide-magazine-inserts-71-topps.html | PADRES | |
| 1991 | Baseball Card Price Guide Magazine Insert Panel of 5 - '71 Topps (Bob Welch/ Joe Carter/Cecil Fielder/Dave Justice/Barry Bonds) | $3.00 |  | PADRES | |
| 1991 | Classic Blue #T21 | $0.50 | PADRES | ||
| 1991 | Classic Maroon #T98 | $0.50 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1991 | Classic Purple #091 | $1.00 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1991 | Dennys Hologram #26 | $1.00 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1991 | Donruss Diamond King # DK-3 | $1.50 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1991 | Fleer #204 (cameo with Lenny Harris - 'NASHVILLE' bolded) | $0.50 |  | PADRES | |
| 1991 | Fleer Update #U-65 | $0.50 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1991 | Info Baseball Game Card (no pic) | $2.00 |  | http://www.supercollectorcatalog.com/1991-info-baseball-game-cards.html | PADRES |
| 1991 | International Playing Cards (4 of Hearts) | $2.00 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1991 | JKA Vincentown Button(light blue/1 inch) | $3.00 | PADRES | ||
| 1991 | Leaf #353 | $0.50 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1991 | OPC Premier #20 | $0.50 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1991 | Panini Canadian Sticker Top 15 #019 | $1.00 |  | PADRES | |
| 1991 | Panini Sticker #90 | $1.00 | PADRES | ||
| 1991 | Score 100 Superstars #81 | $0.50 | PADRES | ||
| 1991 | Score Traded #11T | $0.50 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1991 | Sports Heroes Postercard Series 1 #04 | $5.00 |  | http://www.supercollectorcatalog.com/1991-sports-heroes-postercards.html | PADRES |
| 1991 | Stadium Club #513 | $0.50 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1991 | Statis Pro - Avalon Hill Game Card (no pic) | $2.00 | PADRES | ||
| 1991 | Topps Magazine Insert #TM58 ('86 Topps Replica) | $1.50 | PADRES | ||
| 1991 | Topps Magazine Insert Panel (Ozzie Smith/Joe Carter/ Dave Henderson/Tony Gwynn) | $5.00 |  | BLUE JAYS | |
| 1991 | Topps Micro #120 | $0.50 | PADRES | ||
| 1991 | Topps Tiffany #120 | $2.00 | PADRES | ||
| 1991 | Topps Tiffany Traded #20T | $3.00 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1991 | U.S. Playing Cards - Blue Font Variation (4 of Hearts) | $1.50 |  | http://www.supercollectorcatalog.com/1991-us-playing-cards-variations.html | BLUE JAYS |
| 1991 | U.S. Playing Cards - Blue Font with Pink Highlights Variation (4 of Hearts) | $1.00 |  | http://www.supercollectorcatalog.com/1991-us-playing-cards-variations.html | BLUE JAYS |
| 1991 | U.S. Playing Cards Silver Series (4 of Hearts) | $3.00 |  | BLUE JAYS | |
| 1991 | U.S. Playing Cards Square Oversize Square - Blue Font Variation | $5.00 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1991 | U.S. Playing Cards Square Oversize Square - Blue Font with Pink Highlights Variation | $3.00 |  | BLUE JAYS | |
| 1991 | Upper Deck #765 | $0.50 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1992 | Baseball Card Magazine Insert #64 ('70 Topps Replica) | $1.50 |  | BLUE JAYS | |
| 1992 | Baseball Card Magazine Insert Strip of 4 ('70 Topps Replica - George Bell/McGriff/ Tartabull/Joe Carter) | $2.00 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1992 | Broder Type - John McLean Promo #NNO (blank back) | $1.00 |  | http://www.supercollectorcatalog.com/1992-john-mclean-promos.html | BLUE JAYS |
| 1992 | Classic Blue #011 | $1.00 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1992 | Colla All-Star Game #12 | $1.00 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1992 | Dennys Hologram #26 | $1.00 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1992 | Diet Pepsi MSA #25 | $1.00 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1992 | Donruss Cracker Jack 2nd Series #21 | $1.00 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1992 | Donruss McDonalds Canadian Blue Jays #2 of 6 | $0.75 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1992 | East End Publishing Baseball Superstars Album Poster 8x10 | $3.00 |  | http://www.supercollectorcatalog.com/1992-east-end-publishing-baseball-superstars-album-posters.html | BLUE JAYS |
| 1992 | Fleer All-Star Error(no gold stamping on front) | $3.00 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1992 | Frenchs Mustard #16 (Joe Carter/Tony Gwynn) | $1.50 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1992 | High 5 Reusable Decal | $1.50 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1992 | Jumbo Sunflower Seeds #12 | $1.50 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1992 | Jumbo Sunflower Seeds Oversize Variation (blue border) | $3.00 |  | http://www.supercollectorcatalog.com/1992-jumbow-sunflower-blue-border.html | BLUE JAYS |
| 1992 | Leaf Gold Preview #26 of 33 | $2.00 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1992 | MSA Bens Bread Disc #02 | $3.00 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1992 | MSA King B Disc #24 | $1.50 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1992 | MSA King B Square | $3.00 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1992 | Oh Henry Fanatic Blue Jays Police Single #NNO | $1.50 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1992 | OPC #790 | $0.75 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1992 | Panini Canadian Sticker #29 (Joe Carter #29/Tim Raines Guessing Game #13) | $2.00 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1992 | Panini Sticker #29 (Joe Carter #29/Tim Raines Guessing Game #13) | $0.75 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1992 | Post #12 | $0.50 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1992 | RBI Magazine Insert #11 (1 of 25,000) | $1.50 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1992 | RBI Magazine Insert #11 Oversize(3x5) | $2.00 |  | BLUE JAYS | |
| 1992 | Red Foley Cartoon History - 1986 (on cardstock) | $2.00 |  | http://www.supercollectorcatalog.com/1992-red-foley-cartoon-history.html | INDIANS |
| 1992 | Red Foley Cover Mini (red) | $0.75 |  | BLUE JAYS | |
| 1992 | Red Foley Sticker #023 | $1.00 | http://www.supercollectorcatalog.com/1992-red-foley-stickers.html | BLUE JAYS | |
| 1992 | SCD Baseball Card/Sports Card Price Guide Magazine Insert Strip of 4 (Charles Barkley/ Joe Carter/Kenny Lofton/Scottie Pippen) | $3.00 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1992 | Score Superstar #35 | $0.50 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1992 | Sports Card Price Guide Magazine Insert Strip of 4 | $3.00 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1992 | Stadium Club #845 | $0.50 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1992 | Statis Pro - Avalon Hill Game Card (no pic) | $2.00 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1992 | Topps Gold #790 | $1.50 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1992 | Topps Gold All-Star #402 | $1.00 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1992 | Topps Gold All-Star Winner #402 | $1.00 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1992 | Topps Kids #089 (Single * in Copyright Variation) | $0.50 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1992 | Topps Kids #089 (Two ** in Copyright Variation) | $1.00 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1992 | Topps McDonalds #29 (Single * in Copyright Variation) | $0.75 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1992 | Topps Micro #45 | $1.00 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1992 | Topps Micro #790 | $1.00 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1992 | Topps Micro All-Star #402 | $1.00 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1992 | Topps Tripleheader Ball (Kelly Gruber/Roberto Alomar/Joe Carter) | $6.00 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1992 | Triple Play #108 | $0.50 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1992 | U.S. Playing Card All-Stars (2 of Clubs) | $1.50 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1992 | U.S. Playing Cards Aces Oversize Square Blank Back Variation (2 5/8 x 3 5/8 - 6 of Hearts) | $5.00 | http://www.supercollectorcatalog.com/1992-us-playing-cards-oversize-square.html | BLUE JAYS | |
| 1992 | U.S. Playing Cards Aces Oversize Square Blank Back Variation (2 5/8 x 3 5/8 - 9 of Clubs) | $5.00 | http://www.supercollectorcatalog.com/1992-us-playing-cards-oversize-square.html | BLUE JAYS | |
| 1992 | U.S. Playing Cards Aces Oversize Square Variation (2 5/8 x 3 5/8 - 6 of Hearts) | $2.00 |  | http://www.supercollectorcatalog.com/1992-us-playing-cards-oversize-square.html | BLUE JAYS |
| 1992 | U.S. Playing Cards Aces Oversize Square Variation (2 5/8 x 3 5/8 - 9 of Clubs) | $2.00 |  | http://www.supercollectorcatalog.com/1992-us-playing-cards-oversize-square.html | BLUE JAYS |
| 1992 | Upper Deck HR Heroes #HR6 | $1.00 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1993 | Baseball Card/Sports Card Magazine Insert #47('68 Topps Replica) | $1.50 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1993 | Classic Blue #T19 | $0.50 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1993 | Colla Collection All-Stars #19 | $0.75 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1993 | Dennys Hologram #04 | $1.00 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1993 | Fleer Fruit of the Loom #10 | $2.00 |  | BLUE JAYS | |
| 1993 | Fleer Fruit of the Loom Panel (Albert Belle/Joe Carter) | $3.00 |  | BLUE JAYS | |
| 1993 | Humpty Dumpty #20 | $1.50 |  | http://www.supercollectorcatalog.com/1993-humpty-dumpty.html | BLUE JAYS |
| 1993 | JKA Vincentown Button(red&yellow/1 Inch) | $2.50 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1993 | Metz Bread #NNO | $1.00 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1993 | Metz Bread (In Wrapper Variation) | $2.00 |  | BLUE JAYS | |
| 1993 | Metz Bread Panel of 2 (Joe Carter/Don Mattingly) | $3.00 |  | BLUE JAYS | |
| 1993 | MSA King B Disc #13 | $1.00 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1993 | MSA King B Square | $3.00 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1993 | NJ Education Association "Hit the Books" Bookmark (no pic) | $3.00 |  | BLUE JAYS | |
| 1993 | OPC #3 | $1.00 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1993 | OPC #83 | $1.00 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1993 | OPC Premier Star Perfromer #13 | $1.50 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1993 | Pacific Spanish #322 | $1.00 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1993 | Panini Sticker #031 | $1.00 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1993 | Panini Sticker Panel (Luis Sojo/Dave Stewart/Devon White/Joe Carter/ Roger Clemens/Tony Pena/Mo Vaughn/Scott Cooper) | $6.00 |  | http://www.supercollectorcatalog.com/1993-panini-sticker-panels.html | BLUE JAYS |
| 1993 | Pinnacle Cooperstown Card #21 | $1.00 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1993 | Pinnacle HR Club #07 | $2.00 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1993 | Post Canadian #04 | $1.50 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1993 | Red Foley Sticker #017 | $1.50 | http://www.supercollectorcatalog.com/1993-red-foley-stickers.html | BLUE JAYS | |
| 1993 | Red Foley Sticker #109 | $1.50 | http://www.supercollectorcatalog.com/1993-red-foley-stickers.html | BLUE JAYS | |
| 1993 | SCD Sports Card Price Guide Magazine Insert #076 | $1.50 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1993 | Stadium Club Members Only Parallel #279 | $1.50 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1993 | Strat-O-Matic Game Card (no pic) | $2.00 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1993 | Topps Blank Back Error | $2.00 |  | BLUE JAYS | |
| 1993 | Topps Inaugural Marlins #205 | $2.00 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1993 | Topps Inaugural Marlins #350 | $2.00 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1993 | Topps Micro #205 | $1.00 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1993 | Topps Micro #350 | $1.00 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1993 | Triple Play Pamphlet #30 of 30 | $0.50 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1993 | Ultra #288 | $0.50 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1993 | Upper Deck #219 | $0.50 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1993 | VA Education Association "Hit the Books" Bookmark(no pic) | $3.00 |  | BLUE JAYS | |
| 1994 | Chris Martin Pro Mags #137 | $2.00 |  | BLUE JAYS | |
| 1994 | Churchs Chicken Show Stoppers #08 of 10 | $3.00 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1994 | Collectors Choice Bilingual Wrapper | $0.50 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1994 | Collectors Choice Wrapper | $0.50 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1994 | Fleer Sunoco #06 | $0.50 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1994 | Fun Pack #227 | $0.50 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1994 | Fun Pack #29 | $0.50 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1994 | Info Baseball Game Card (no pic) | $1.50 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1994 | Innovative Confections Sucker Saver Disc #05 | $3.00 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1994 | Innovative Confections Sucker Saver Square | $3.00 |  | BLUE JAYS | |
| 1994 | Leaf #193 | $0.50 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1994 | Leaf Power Brokers #9 | $2.00 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1994 | OPC Jumbo All-Stars #23 | $2.00 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1994 | Pacific Spanish #636 | $1.00 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1994 | Pacific Spanish Box Cut Mini | $1.00 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1994 | Panini Sticker #136 | $1.00 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1994 | Panini Sticker Boxside | $2.00 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1994 | Panini Sticker Panel (Pat Borders/Joe Carter/ Tony Fernandez/Juan Guzman/ Ron Gant/Tom Glavine/Dave Justice/Greg Maddux) | $8.00 |  | http://www.supercollectorcatalog.com/1994-panini-sticker-panels.html | BLUE JAYS |
| 1994 | Post Canadian #01 | $2.00 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1994 | Post Canadian (In Wrapper Variation) | $2.00 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1994 | Red Foley Card | $2.00 |  | http://www.supercollectorcatalog.com/1994-red-foley-cards.html | BLUE JAYS |
| 1994 | Score Gold Rush #625 | $1.00 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1994 | Score Gold Rush #73 | $1.00 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1994 | Select #12 | $0.50 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1994 | Sportflics #12 | $0.50 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1994 | Sportflics #183 | $0.50 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1994 | Sports Heroes Feats & Facts - Baseball Champion #038 Pkt.14 variation (Highlights: 4-Time All-Star Selection/How Good Is He? List order is Carter/Canseco/McGriff/Bonds/Fielder/Puckett/Mattingly) | $3.00 |  | http://www.supercollectorcatalog.com/1994-sports-heroes-feats--facts---all.html | BLUE JAYS |
| 1994 | Sports Heroes Feats & Facts - Bloopers & Trivia #023 Pkt.09 variation | $2.00 | http://www.supercollectorcatalog.com/1994-sports-heroes-feats--facts---all.html | BLUE JAYS | |
| 1994 | Sports Heroes Feats & Facts - Record Book #019 Pkt.01 variation | $2.00 | http://www.supercollectorcatalog.com/1994-sports-heroes-feats--facts---all.html | BLUE JAYS | |
| 1994 | Sports Heroes Feats & Facts - Record Book #019 Pkt.01a variation | $2.00 | http://www.supercollectorcatalog.com/1994-sports-heroes-feats--facts---all.html | BLUE JAYS | |
| 1994 | Stadium Club Golden Rainbow #300 | $2.00 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1994 | Stadium Club Members Only Parallel #300 | $3.00 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1994 | Stadium Club Members Only Parallel #527 | $3.00 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1994 | Topps Spanish #645 | $2.00 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1994 | Triple Play #32 | $0.50 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1994 | Ultra #136 | $0.50 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1994 | Upper Deck Iooss All-Star Jumbos #24 (John Olerud, Joe Carter) | $1.50 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1995 | Kraft #02 | $1.00 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1995 | Pinnacle #52 | $0.50 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1995 | Post Canadian #08 | $1.50 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1995 | Post Canadian (In Wrapper Variation) | $2.00 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1995 | Red Foley Card | $1.50 |  | http://www.supercollectorcatalog.com/1995-red-foley-cards.html | BLUE JAYS |
| 1995 | Sports Heroes Feats & Facts - Record Book #019 Pkt.01b variation | $2.00 | http://www.supercollectorcatalog.com/1994-sports-heroes-feats--facts---all.html | BLUE JAYS | |
| 1995 | Stadium Club Super Team World Series #215 | $1.00 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1995 | Stadium Club Super Team World Series #281 | $1.00 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1995 | Stadium Club Super Team World Series #523 | $1.00 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1995 | Topps D3#55 | $0.75 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1995 | Upper Deck #59 | $0.50 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1996 | Chris Martin Pro Mags Die Cut Magnet | $4.00 |  | BLUE JAYS | |
| 1996 | Chris Martin Pro Stamps #018 | $1.50 | http://www.supercollectorcatalog.com/1996-pro-stamps.html | BLUE JAYS | |
| 1996 | Panini Sticker #162 | $1.00 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1996 | Panini Sticker Strip of 3 (Paul Molitor/Shawn Green/Joe Carter) | $2.00 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1996 | Saim C.A. Venezuelan Sticker #085 | $6.00 |  | BLUE JAYS | |
| 1996 | Sports Heroes Feats & Facts - Bloopers & Trivia #023 Pkt.09d variation | $2.00 | http://www.supercollectorcatalog.com/1994-sports-heroes-feats--facts---all.html | BLUE JAYS | |
| 1996 | Sports Heroes Feats & Facts - Record Book #019 Pkt.01d variation | $2.00 | http://www.supercollectorcatalog.com/1994-sports-heroes-feats--facts---all.html | BLUE JAYS | |
| 1996 | Sports Heroes Feats & Facts - Record Book #019 Pkt.01e variation | $2.00 | http://www.supercollectorcatalog.com/1994-sports-heroes-feats--facts---all.html | BLUE JAYS | |
| 1996 | Stadium Club Members Only Parallel #129 | $3.00 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1996 | Team Out Baseball Card | $1.00 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1996 | Upper Deck Folz Vending Machine Minis #34 | $5.00 |  | http://www.supercollectorcatalog.com/1996-upper-deck-folz-vending-minis.html | BLUE JAYS |
| 1997 | King B Disc #13 | $1.50 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 1997 | Sports Heroes Feats & Facts - Baseball Champion #038 Pkt.14b variation (Highlights: 5-Time All-Star Selection/How Good Is He? List order is Bonds/Canseco/Carter/McGriff/McGwire/Murray/Ripken) | $3.00 |  | http://www.supercollectorcatalog.com/1994-sports-heroes-feats--facts---all.html | BLUE JAYS |
| 1997 | Sports Heroes Feats & Facts - Record Book #019 Pkt.01f variation | $2.00 | http://www.supercollectorcatalog.com/1994-sports-heroes-feats--facts---all.html | BLUE JAYS | |
| 1998 | Donruss Silver Press Proofs Series 2 #203 /1500 | $2.00 |  | ORIOLES | |
| 1998 | Topps Chrome #209 (cameo with Luis Alicea) | $1.00 |  | BLUE JAYS | |
| 1998 | Topps Inaugural Diamondbacks #145 | $1.00 | BLUE JAYS | ||
| 2002 | Upper Deck Championship Caliber #CC2 (cameo with Roberto Alomar and Rickey Henderson) | $1.00 |  | BLUE JAYS | |
| 2011 | Fundex All About Baseball Trivia (no pic) #19 | $2.00 | http://www.supercollectorcatalog.com/2011-fundex-all-about-baseball-trivia.html | BLUE JAYS | |
| 2017 | Big Book of Who - Baseball Facts and Trivia 8x10 (on cardstock with label) 002728 | $3.00 |  | http://www.supercollectorcatalog.com/2017-big-book-of-who---baseball-facts-and-trivia-8x10s.html | BLUE JAYS |
| 2022 | Main Street Baseball Customs #NNO (blank back) | $3.00 |  | http://www.supercollectorcatalog.com/2022-main-street-baseball-customs.html | INDIANS |
| 2022 | Main Street Baseball Customs #NNO (with original barcode from 1989) | $6.00 |  | http://www.supercollectorcatalog.com/2022-main-street-baseball-customs.html | INDIANS |